Nacogdoches custom cake bakeryCustom cakes, baked fresh to order
A small, family-focused local bakery in Nacogdoches, Texas, making custom buttercream cakes for birthdays, gender reveals, anniversaries, simple weddings, and just because.
- Cakes from $65
- Made to order
- Free delivery in Nacogdoches
Request a quote
Tell us about your celebration and Lauren will reply within two business days.
Trouble with the form? Email lauren@poppycakesbakingco.com
Custom cakes for every occasion
Every Poppy Cakes cake is a custom, single-tier buttercream cake, designed with you, made to order here in Nacogdoches with locally sourced ingredients, and delivered to your door.
Birthday cakes
From first birthdays to milestone years.
Gender reveal cakes
The big news stays hidden until the first slice.
Anniversary cakes
A sweet way to mark another year together.
Just because
Some days simply deserve cake.
Simple wedding cakes
Elegant single-tier cakes for intimate celebrations.
And more
If you're celebrating, we'd love to bake for it.
Find your cake size
Pick a size to see how many it serves and where custom cake pricing starts.
- Your cake
- Serves
- Starts at
Starting prices. Your final quote is set once Lauren sees your design, colors, and decorations.
How ordering works
From first idea to delivery day. Scroll to walk through each step, or tap one to jump to it.
Start your quote-
Share your date, how many guests you're serving, flavor ideas, and any inspiration photos. Please order at least 10 days ahead.
Open the quote form -
She checks her calendar, asks any follow-up questions, and sends your price within two business days.
See starting prices -
A 50% non-refundable deposit, sent as an invoice, holds your spot. We take a limited number of orders each week, so earlier is better.
-
Your cake is made to order here in Nacogdoches with locally sourced ingredients, so it's fresh for your celebration.
-
We deliver free anywhere in Nacogdoches, and within about a 30-minute drive for a fee included in your quote. Then all that's left is to celebrate.
Start your quote
Cake inspiration
A few of the looks our customers love. Hover or tap a cake to take a closer look.
Loved by our customers
Five-star Google reviews from families across Nacogdoches.
The custom cake we got for our 1 year olds birthday party was unbelievable! It was exactly what we were looking for. And there was NONE left because of how delicious it was!! Thank you Poppy Cakes Banking Co.!!
Poppy Cakes was amazing!! The birthday cake tasted amazing and was exactly what we asked for! They were so easy to work with! Thank you Poppy Cakes!!
Poppy cakes makes the tastiest and most beautiful custom cakes! The colors are beautiful and the attention to detail sets them apart! Highly recommend for birthday party cakes or any special event!
Poppy Cakes is legit! The service is second to none. The owner is very sweet and cares about making the cake special for the occasion. Easily the best place in Nac for a birthday cake or graduation cake.
Amazing birthday cake for my cousins birthday party, will definitely be going back for future events
Poppy Cakes did an awesome job with our kids birthday cakes. So yummy and kids taste test approved! She did everything perfect that we wanted for our custom cakes. Everyone should use Poppy Cakes in Nacogdoches!
Your local bakery in Nacogdoches
Poppy Cakes is a small, made-to-order bakery right here in Nacogdoches. There's no storefront display case here: every cake is baked for your date, finished by hand in real buttercream, and delivered fresh to your home or party.
Lauren designs each cake with you, whether you have an inspiration photo, a party theme, or just a favorite color. Whether you're a Nacogdoches family, an SFA student planning a friend's birthday, or a neighbor in a nearby East Texas town, we'd love to bake for your celebration.
- Baked to orderMade fresh for your date
- Free delivery in NacogdochesAnd within about 30 minutes of town for a fee
- Cakes from $656 to 12 inch, serving 5 to 60 guests
- Vanilla, chocolate, lemonPlus rotating seasonal flavors
Named for Poppy
Poppy Cakes is named for Lauren's grandmother, Poppy, who passed away in the spring of 2026.
Lauren started Poppy Cakes to create a space where people feel truly celebrated. Baking is her creative outlet, but the heart of it is the people, and giving back to Nacogdoches and East Texas in a meaningful way.
Read our storyWe're booking up fast
We limit the number of orders we take so every cake gets our full attention. Please order at least 10 days ahead. Delivery is free anywhere in Nacogdoches.